• >
  • Guides>
  • Diesel or petrol: which is best for you?

Is a petrol or diesel car better?

There are numerous things to consider when buying a new car, from a preferred or familiar make and model to expert reviews and even colour, but fuel is right up there as a vital factor. Here we gauge what’s best: diesel or petrol motors.

How do diesel and petrol cars differ?

When it comes to fuel petrol versus diesel is not like Coke versus Pepsi. It’s not a matter or taste, in any shape of form. It’s all about how it makes your engine run, and how it affects the environment. 

The big difference between petrol and diesel is that they combust in different ways. Petrol will ignite when in contact with spark plugs, diesel needs to be compressed to produce enough heat to fire, which is arguably more efficient.

In both cases, once there is an explosion the energy drives the pistons which get the car moving.

What’s cheaper to buy, diesel vs petrol?

It costs around 5p a litre to fill up a petrol car, despite the wholesale cost of both fuels being roughly the same. This is because two thirds of road vehicles are petrol driven, and most of these are run by private individuals.

When it comes to diesel, this fuels most haulage lorries, HVGs, black cabs and other commercial vehicles. These drivers work to schedules and are more concerned with making their delivery on time that finding the cheapest filling station, plus they don’t pay for the fuel.

Petrol versus diesel, what’s cheaper to run?

If petrol takes the plaudits for fuel pump prices, diesel storms ahead when it comes to performance. Benefiting from compressed fuel injection, diesel cars produces around 15% more oomph, according to the European Automobile Manufacturers Association.

On the downside, diesel engines are usually heavier than petrol ones. This has implications for acceleration from a standing start, and of course for fuel costs.

Of course, this all depends on how the car is driven, and while turbo charged petrol cars can narrow the gap, diesels still boss the motorways. It can cruise at higher speeds with less effort, as well as overtake with greater effectiveness thanks to its low speed torque.

What is cheaper to tax, diesel or petrol cars?

The wholesale price of petrol and diesel is roughly the same in part because the two fuels are taxed at the same rate. However, the tax rate for diesel and petrol cars differs. 

Diesel cars tend to pay more than petrol cars because of the level of emissions they produce. The Real Driving Emissions 2 standards (RDE2) dictate that diesel cars that don’t meet the standards are taxed at a higher rate than they were when first registered.

What is cheaper to insure, petrol or diesel?

As diesel cars tend to be more expensive to buy, due to their more powerful engines, it follows that it costs more to insure them. 

Insurers also take into account the greater cost of services, repairs and replacement parts for diesel cars when setting premiums.

Why do diesel engines get such a bad time?

Diesel is cleaner than petrol when it comes to CO2 emissions. This is why it was the darling of the motor press for donkey’s years. But, it has its faults, which include:

  • diesels have a particle filter attached to the exhaust pipe to trap dangerous emissions. Soot builds up in this over time, which can damage the car, unless it is driven far enough on a motorway to incinerate the residue

  • diesels typically need an AdBlue-reliant selective catalytic reduction system, which fires a liquid-reductant agent thought to the exhaust to help control emissions, without dampening performance 

  • with CO2 emissions in petrol cars under control, all eyes are on the damage to the environment diesel motors can cause, not least as they produce more noxious fumes than petrol, since leaded fuel has been outlawed

Petrol vs diesel engine pros and cons?

Since the dawn of lead-free petrol engines, CO2 and car exhaust emissions have not been a big issue. The same cannot be said for diesel. 

Recent research from Oxford and Bath Universities cast a shadow over the motor industry when it concluded that diesel fuel emissions cause 10,000 premature deaths annually in the UK.

Why are diesel car fumes so dangerous?

While all the world’s attention was on CO2 and leaded petrol, diesel continued to be pumped out by the gallon at service stations the length and breadth of the country. Recently, though it has been made apparent that diesel carries its own deadly risks.

Nitrogen oxides and particulate matter, or PM2.5, are the two biggest concerns scientists and other interested parties have about diesel. The former can cause respiratory problems, the latter emits minute particles of soot and other nasties into the atmosphere.

Do MOT tests for petrol and diesel cars differ?

Diesel and petrol cars have been required to take more rigorous MOT tests since 2018, although the nature of the test differs for both.

Special attention is paid to the diesel particle filter (DPF), which is attached to exhaust pipes to trap harmful emissions. These can build up over time and if during the MOT smoke of any colour is seen, or the DPF has been fiddled with, the car will fail the MOT.

Exhaust emissions from petrol engines are also scrutinised. If blue or black smoke is detected coming out of the exhaust pipe for a continuous period of five seconds at idle, the car will fail the test.

What does the future hold for petrol and diesel cars?

Restrictions are already imposed on petrol and diesel cars if they are driven in certain parts of the country, such as in London’s Ultra-Low Emission Zone, but this is just a taster for the future.

The government plans to ban the sale of new diesel and petrol cars from 2035 as part of its drive to make the UK carbon-free by 2050. 

This is expected to result in fewer new petrol and diesel models being introduced in the future, and costs increase as more punitive tax levels and legislation are introduced.

Car insurance is just one of the costs of keeping your car on the road along with tax, petrol and servicing, so cut your insurance costs by comparing the best deals for you.