NHS Spends £32m a Year on Hospital Chaplains: Money Well Spent?

by Charlotte Cardingham
Published on 8 April 2009

These religious provisions, funded by taxpayer money, could instead be used to pay for 1,300 extra nurses or 2,645 cleaners.

Figures out today have revealed that the NHS (National Health Service) is spending upwards of £32 million a year employing religious personnel in its hospitals – an amount that could be used to fund an extra 1,300 nurses or 2,645 cleaners instead.

After obtaining the data under the Freedom of Information Act, the National Secular Society (NSS - which represents atheists, agnostics and other non-believers) is now calling for Health Minister Ben Bradshaw and the Department of Health to conduct a full scale investigation into whether this money could be better spent elsewhere.

The NSS have suggested that the cost should be footed by churches and religious organisations rather than the tax payer.

As part of their research the NSS contacted each NHS mental and acute health trust within the UK asking for information on their outlay for religious services. 

From these they received 233 detailed responses back, together amounting to a total spend of £26.72million a year on religious services, with each hospital chaplain costing the NHS an average £48,953 a year.

Once they extrapolated these figures to encompass spending within all NHS trusts they were able to approximate a total annual spend of over £32 million on clergy staff.

However, according to the NSS, this sizable amount is just the tip of the iceberg as it accounts for salary payments alone and doesn’t take into consideration other ‘extras’ funded by the taxpayer.

They estimated that it was necessary to add a ‘conservative 20%’ to this figure in order to represent additional costs such as pension and national insurance contributions, training, office and administration costs and the upkeep of chapels and prayer rooms also incurred by NHS trusts. This would pitch the total spend upwards of £40 million a year and still not cover the organist fees and call-out charges requested by some chaplains.

President of the NSS Terry Sanderson commented:"We are not asking for an end to chaplaincy services, but we are asking that the taxpayer not be made responsible for them."

"In these times of financial stringency, hospitals are going to have to think very carefully about how they spend their budgets.

"It would be better if their own vicar, priest, rabbi or imam came to see them if they felt in need of religious support.

"I think if people were given the choice they would choose the latter [nurses or cleaners] because frontline services are under pressure, they are going to be increasingly so as the recession bites, and it's important that savings are made wherever they can be" he said.

In response, a representative of the Department of Health said it was "committed to the principle of ensuring that NHS patients have access to the spiritual care that they want, whatever faith or belief system they follow"

Source

Get our free money saving newsletter
Join over 480,000 other subscribers who grab our expert money tips, unmissable money guides & hottest bargains each week in our special email...
 
12

Your Comments

Chris
on 18 Apr 2009 00:02
Money well spent? Yes
 
Patrick
on 13 Apr 2009 22:03
Chaplains work very hard, and give a great deal of comfort. They certainly don't earn £48,950 - so we need to know how this alleged figure is arrived at. The National Secular Society has one purpose - to make people secular. And how much comfort have they ever given to sick and dying patients? None.
 
Briboy
on 12 Apr 2009 20:28
If cleaners and patient care nurses had this money extra maybe fewer chaplins will be needed!
 
yvonne corbett
on 9 Apr 2009 13:55
The service of spiritual care is important to lthe process of healing.I believe the chapels and prayer rooms should be maintained but money must be made available to the necessary nurses and cleaners of hospitals.Volunteers from the church must be allowed to particpate in the spiritual healing the patients must receive. I am sure the church will be able to understand why money should be shifted to take care of the health care and cleanliness of hospitals.
 
Irish
on 9 Apr 2009 13:36
WOW - I can't believe some of the comments made here nor can I believe that there was a study of how many chaplains there are in hospitals and whether or not they're deemed "useful" enough. For those of you who claim there is no God or feel that a chaplain's presence consoling a grieving or ill person is just a form of pushing religion down your throats, shame on you! A world without faith and hope becomes a violent and desperate world - just about where we are today. I don't see a single hospital chaplain chasing down after every patient or visitor in hospital in order to spread his or her theological beliefs. People are free to avoid "religion," but the basis of all religion is for peace, love, hope, and compassion. God forbid any of those things exist - we might just be a happier, safer, and peaceful world.
 
Rosemary
on 9 Apr 2009 12:40
Chaplins provide comfort to those who are in pain, frightened, or dying. They relieve nurses of the responsibility of holding hands and calming distressed patients so they can do what they are trained for, All educated people know there is a relationship between mental stress and physical health. Providing comfort and reassurance for those in stress, and being in the hospital is always stressful, IS contributing to their medical care.
 
Jim
on 8 Apr 2009 22:48
Yes. We know. The NHS is inefficient with money. They probably spend a similar amount on bath plugs.
 
obviousguy
on 8 Apr 2009 20:20
obviously, this is retarded. shame on religious leaders who think this was ever a good idea. if your santa-god 'can cure you' with his 'miracles', he certainly wouldn't need a hospital to do it. for those looking for guidance in a hospital bed - that's what your 'magic book of rape and murder' is for. morons.
 
Nick
on 8 Apr 2009 18:48
YOU WHAT!?
 
anon
on 8 Apr 2009 18:35
seriously?
 
James Smith
on 8 Apr 2009 18:33
This is just one more example of religious organizations forcing their perverted beliefs on everyone else and then adding insult to injury by making us pay for it. When will humanity be freed from the yoke of religion?
 
ELK_1
on 8 Apr 2009 18:29
didn't see any chaplain when i went to see my deceased father, probably not there. Hey-ho, there it is