House of Lords Backs Banks in New Charges Case

by Peter Wakeford
Published on 2 April 2009
House of Lords Backs Banks in New Charges Case

Hopes of a quick resolution for bank charges claimants have been dashed by the latest events.

Customers trying to reclaim overdraft charges from their banks via the ongoing High Court test case have suffered another legal setback, in a new decision from the House of Lords.

The latest verdict allows banks to dispute a previous decision from the Court of Appeal - which ruled that the financial firms were subject to contract fairness laws. This adds a new twist to the torturous legal history of the High Court case looking into the charges, which was called in 2007 to decide on whether or not they were unfair to customers.

All individual cases of customers reclaiming these fees - which came to around £30 each and were levied by banks for offences including exceeding overdraft limits - were frozen by the Financial Services Authority when the test case began in 2007. Customers have been warned not to expect any refunds for months, with banks showing little sign of giving up the fight against paying the charges back.

Consumer groups expressed dismay at the latest verdict. Doug Taylor, personal finance campaigns manager at Which?, said: "It's outrageous that public money is being used to drag this saga out for even longer when the banks should accept the Court of Appeal's decision and draw a line under this issue once and for all. Not only are the banks prolonging the misery for their customers, many of whom are struggling to make ends meet, they are doing further damage to their already battered public image."

James Caldwell at Fairinvestment.co.uk added: "This latest news is just another delaying tactic by the banks, the test case has been going on for long enough now."

Campaigners hope that the High Court case will eventually agree to let the Office of Fair Trading decide on the charges' fairness. The organisation is anticipated to rule that the fees are unfair, which in turn could lead to banks beginning the refunds.

Get our free money saving newsletter
Join over 480,000 other subscribers who grab our expert money tips, unmissable money guides & hottest bargains each week in our special email...
 
3

Your Comments

Tony
on 23 Apr 2009 05:18
I wonder how many of the illustrious 'Lords' are connected with the banks....
 
Steve Gresty
on 6 Apr 2009 00:17
Well, if we did need any more proof that that deals in gentleman's clubs exist this is it. The whole political/banking system in this country is so undeniably corrupt, Politician expenses, second/third homes, Bankers pensions etc. You all should hang your head in shame!!!! Disgusting!!!!
 
dave
on 4 Apr 2009 14:23
Looks and smells like the "lodge" has been brought into the equation again, can't have the great unwashed upsetting our masters. I am sure that the recent massive rise in the popularity of the far right despite all the concentrated power of the media is largely due to a total disgust towards our so called leaders who have been shown as greedy, sleazy buffoons who are incapable of honourable behaviour. Roll on the general election, if Leeds is anything to go by, there will be shocks and hopefully a party who will not be bound by the lodge and sleaze. Never thought I want to vote extreme left or right but we need someone to clean the augean stables of parliament.